Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_ACCEPT_LANGUAGE" in /var/www/minitokyo/www/includes/common.inc.php on line 360 Weskalia's Black Cat Tv Review - Minitokyo
»

Weskalia's Black Cat Tv Review

Black Cat

Black Cat tv Review

Train Heartnet became known as the Black Cat due to his skills and his place as Number 13 in the secret society “Chronos”. With his gun Hades, he unfeelingly murdered uncountable people at Chronos’ demand. This was until he met Saya Minatsuki, a bounty hunter or “Sweeper” who teaches him the meaning of human life.
Enraged at how Saya had changed Train, Creed Diskenth, a fellow member of Chronos, murders Saya. Saya’s murder results in Train completely forsaking the organization and following a new life as a Sweeper.
On his new path, Train joins up with fellow Sweeper, the carefree Sven Vollfied, and later the mysterious Eve. Train believes his old life is behind him until Creed reappears, asking Train to help him overthrow Chronos.

Contributed by DokiDokiChan

Story & Characters

Number thirteen and the black cats, we fear and detest them, don't we? Consider they are omens of bad luck and disaster. Funny enough, these two are mixed together to create a good series, Black Cat.

Chronos, an organization bent on world peace, rules one third of the world's economy. To maintain the balance of the world, Chronos is therefore essential, and there is a need for people to protect Chronos. Thirteen special elite assassins each possess unique orichalcum-forged weapons and are called the Numbers, Chronos' erasers. The thirteenth member, Train Heartnet (aka "Black Cat"), is a merciless assassin with peerless marksmanship and prominent skills in combat; his duties consist of killing anyone, anywhere, and he is very good at it, earning many notorious reputations much like the nickname and number he bears. Train's moral and value of human lives and society are changed after meeting a female sweeper named Minatsuki Saya. This eventually leads to his decision of leaving Chronos to live a free, wayward life of a sweeper whilst learning to appreciate it and maintaining his skill, which is good because things ain't gonna be pretty when Train's secret stalker, Creed Diskenth, launches a world revolution to overthrown Chronos. The battle's on!

It's usually a bad sign when the title character is also the least interesting one in the show. Train Heartnet has some wicked moves, the thing going with the cat, a large appetite and an allegedly "cool" look. It's interesting to see he transforms from a stone-cold killer to a free-willed, compassionate traveler, but those aren't new, in fact, many works have featured this character archetype (Himura Kenshin or Vash the Stampede). Even the most hardcore action heroes have at least something to keep them more and more appealing, but all Mr. Black Cat has is some hilarious scenes and fancy moves. It's not a bad thing, but not much. Sven with his vision eye, trick briefcase and "Mr. Nice Guy" attitude make him a truly funny and likable character as the same goes for child bio weapon Eve; her background isn't hardly new, but her interesting and sympathetic characters, interactions with Sven and cuteness work well.

Black Cat isn't a bad show, but its concept is overran with lack of originality. How many times before have the "youth trained as an expert killer and working for a secret organization," the "special drinks will grant you superpower or you will lose your life if it doesn't work" or the "we dominate over the world in the name of peace" concepts been done? The anime's weak execution can also be counted negative as it wind itself up to fever pitch, serving up its big climax a full four episodes before the end of the series. The series still has Eve and its amusing jokes can make up for this mess.

Rating: 7

Art

The character design of Black Cat looks better than its manga counterpart, featuring many good-looking hitmen and moe type characters. Example, just take a look at Train, such an intensive glare he has, with this, he stands among some of the most notorious heroes who have deadly eyes. The series' design did a decent job in showing a futuristic city to an old American Wild West remote town.

Other than the frantic attempts to distinguish itself stylistically, Black Cat's animation is purely basic. Yeah, as much as Gonzo's works are known for their great deal in animation, this show uses exaggeratedly colorful, erratic visual to support the fight scenes. These action sets are some of the most intricately staged, overstate animated fight sequences in anime history. They are also almost hilariously dynamic at times as blood, sparks and major explosions get bombarded in full view of the camera. As the heat spices up a little, so does the excitement, but there is none of Gonzo's trademark CGs.

Rating: 7

Sound

The musical score samples from themes one would more expect from a classic Western, especially in its lightly comic moments, but is otherwise not especially remarkable. Three pieces of music were used for Black Cat: OP "Daia no Hana" is a mix of simple instrumentals, techno backbeat, orchestral bombast, and overwrought operatic vocals that is used primarily as invisible background support while the first ED is a lighter, cutesy tone with cat-themed as backgrounds and the second is sad melody with an airy singing voice. However, the best song of the entire series is that lovely tune sung by Saya.

Voice actings, on the other hand, don't compare well with the better efforts put on the music, some qualities in voices are slightly different in many case. Voiced by Kondou Takashi, Train sounds a bit plain, boring for his cool hero type when his child seiyuu, Takayama Minami, performed a better role. Sven's gravelly voice and Eve's cold yet child-like tone make the pair even more appealing as the series progresses. Some more specific examples are Creed's insanity and Sephiria's heroism are more than enough to convince they are a few of many good fits.

Rating: 7

Presentation

To say that Black Cat is a bad show wouldn't be fair to its sporadically entertaining qualities, but it certainly isn't a complete good show either. If only it was without the "reject and escape from the organization that made you a killer" track, half-hearted cliche and with so many superior examples of the genre out there, it could have been better. A more solid writing, more exciting originalities to make it flourished are hard to imagine. The endearing qualities are in place, from the supporting cast - particularly Eve and Sven - to the weird yet amusing insertions of humor. Black Cat is still the first and probably most successful its author ever created, it indeed does leave a good impression that Train and Eve made appearance in his later works. Aside from those, the series' overriding mediocrity.
____________________________________________________________________________________________
Story: 6
Characters: 7
Art: 8
Animation: 6
Voice: 6
Music: 7
Overall: 7
Good:
+A good mix of flashy actions and some funny jokes; isn't terrible.
+Eve is appealing.
Bad:
+Not exactly the most original concept in the world.
+Fights made insensible by over-enthusiastic stylization.
+Last episodes, occasionally descend to extreme rush.

Rating: 6

Final Verdict

6.6667 (above average)

Reviewed by Weskalia, Feb 26, 2011

Comments

  1. CyanideBlizzard Retired Moderator Feb 27, 2011

    It sounds like you had the same problems with this show that I did.

    Originally, I had stopped watching it because of it. While the beginning was absurdly cliche, I loved it. Especially when you-know-who got killed off. It was a great time to make Train grow as a character, but his transition is instantaneous. Jumping from one personality to another so quickly just pulled me out of the anime and I stopped caring about him as a character. While the second time I viewed it I was able to finish it, but I just couldn't help wishing for more. There were such great concepts, so it was rather sad to see it not live up to what it could of been.

  2. MisaSasekage Moderator Feb 27, 2011

    I like Black Cat, even though it could've been better. Got into it because of a friend of mine. I hated it when Saya got killed, for some reason I really liked her. Creed creeped me/ticked me off out with his whole stalker attitude about Train though.

  3. aozoraskies Feb 28, 2011

    I wonder if 6.83 is too high a grade for Black Cat, lol. It's premise wasn't anything new but it was sort of appealing in the 'stylization', but as you said, it really isn't all too original, overall. And I'll always have a little grudge with Gonzo for being promising but nearly always pushing things too far to the point of overkill ^_^; and then suddenly stuttering as it nears the end (budget cuts? >_>) and rushing wildly to finish the job. :argh:

    What I do like about Black Cat is the battle artstyle admittedly, but it could have done with more filling out on character and less filler.. I really didn't see the point of episodes like that with Saya's near-doppelganger, as sort-of-meaningful as it was, and the 13th's copycat kind of got on my nerves (especially since it had been done before and all). And so many character introductions piled onto the audience in the last few episodes and happy, sappy endings for villians and not-quite-logical secret mecha weapons.. Gah. Not to mention, Creed's exaggeration and mad laughing started to grate on my nerves a bit much; the guy just couldn't give up on Train. Not that his 'happy ending' made much sense either.. way too mellow.

    Was quite saddened by how how everything turned out, was like, WUT? I sat through all that for that? Yep. It had promise in the introduction with all the Saya/Train, Eve/Sven, Sven/Train interactions and the er, interesting battles, and Creed's obsession for savagery and beauty could have been mildly appealing for a villian - but in the end, it descended into a kind of messed up slush. With shiny, shiny mecha. Gah Gonzo! Sigh.

    Still, nice concise review, not too long winding. :) Good job.

    merged: 02-28-2011 ~ 04:35am
    P.S. Erm, I forgot to point out the grammar in these sentences seem a bit off.

    Quote: Black Cat is still the first and probably most successful its author ever created, it indeed does leave a good impression that Train and Eve made appearance in his later works. Aside from those, the series' overriding mediocrity.

    Do you mean, something like "...it indeed left a good impression of Train and Eve when they made an appearance in his later works. However, the series' mediocrity overrode that" ..er.. ",unfortunately." ?_? Does that work better

  4. ChronusXIII Feb 28, 2011

    I don't think Black Cat is a good show. I think it's the best. Probably you people think I am nuts XD I have watched a lot of animes of them Black Cat certainly be in top 10 list. Hmm let's see.
    1. Death Note
    2. Code Geass
    3. Darker Than Black
    4. Welcome to the N.H.K
    5. GITS series
    6. Black Cat
    7. Saiyuki series
    8. Bacanno
    9. Naruto
    10. Bleach

    I understand people have different tastes on anime. I might feel upset because people are saying bad stuff about the anime's character I am using XD

    XIII is my favorite character.

  5. zathurian Feb 28, 2011

    @Chronus XIII
    Dude your list upside down would be close to my top 10 list. Means 2 things.1 I enjoy anime with a great deal of emotion in them. Not just cold hearted logical thinking all the time but then thats why Death note will come in 10th. But heck I think Black Cat is an awesome anime too. The music trax, the scenes in the beginning of him "delivering bad luck". The fight filled with frustration and rage at greed when he murdered saya. The way he completely and utterly put the metal beak faced guy to shame.
    All in all I think its an anime I will watch quite frequently. And hey I've seen like 400 GB worth of stuff (all 60 mb mkv files) so yes I think I'm also qualified to say that black cat is one of the best. I would have given it an 8-9 in rating.

  6. nixhel Mar 01, 2011

    Thanks for the detailed review, Weskalia-san (^_^) I'd give the anime a 6.5 rating. I watched this show back when Funimation first released the DVDs and was rather disappointed that it wasn't as good as the manga. On the whole, it was an entertaining series and I felt, on the overall, the original voice acting, the graphics & music were well done. The art and story was kind of blah towards the end ?_? One of my favourite parts of the anime was the first ED animation - the fluffy nyan-nyan hand puppets :3

  7. CyanideBlizzard Retired Moderator Mar 02, 2011

    Quote by zathurianAll in all I think its an anime I will watch quite frequently. And hey I've seen like 400 GB worth of stuff (all 60 mb mkv files) so yes I think I'm also qualified to say that black cat is one of the best. I would have given it an 8-9 in rating.

    That would be like me saying that I've owned enough anime over the years to where I could buy a rather nice car brand new. However, regardless of that it doesn't make me an expert. All it simply comes down to is personal opinion, not how much you've watched or how much you own ; ).

  8. BCblackcat Mar 24, 2011

    i love this manga...i think the manga is more interesting than the anime..anyway, the anime ending is a happy ending
    i'm wondering why there is no art book.....I can only find the to love

page 1 of 1 8 total items

Only members can post replies, please register.

Warning: Undefined array key "cookienotice" in /var/www/minitokyo/www/html2/footer.html on line 73
This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Read more.