Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_ACCEPT_LANGUAGE" in /var/www/minitokyo/www/includes/common.inc.php on line 360 g-money's Mahou Sensei Negima! Tv Review - Minitokyo
»

g-money's Mahou Sensei Negima! Tv Review

Mahou Sensei Negima!

Mahou Sensei Negima! tv Review

Ten-year-old Negi Springfield is a wizard who wants to become a Magister Magi. The task of teaching him is given to 31 students at an all-girl school. At school he gains new friends and learns new things, whether he wants to or not.
Negi endures tiresome training for both his wizarding skills and his physical strength. He is given difficult tasks that forces him against a dragon, other wizards, mad-scientists and an evil vampire... and they just keep getting more tougher!

Written by super-anime-fan

Story & Characters

Typical of Ken Akamatsu, this is another series full of fanservice and near-naked girls, but in a totally different direction - school and magic. I think that it is unrealistic to have a 10-year-old be a professor of modern English teaching to a group of girls all older than him by at least 3 years, but whatever, I'm not going to argue with the author of Love Hina, greatest manga of all time. Other than that, the story is pretty original with Negi Springfield trying his hardest to help everyone, searching for his father, and trying to be a magister all at the same time. This anime faithfully follows the first 6 volumes of Negima! Magister Negi Magi with some elements from later volumes like the time machine and the meaning of Asuna's magic-nulling ability. The last 4-5 episodes called the "Asuna's death" story arc was highly original if anything. Fights, chaos, love, death, and magic are perhaps equally shown throughout the series; explained more in detail later. Our hero Negi seems to be the stereotypical little kid who tries his best to face against all odds with magic at his disposal. As typical of harem anime, there are 31 girls with their own personalities to boot. The girls include Kagurazaka Asuna, the fiery hot-head and lead female protagonist with a mysterious past, Konoe Konoka, best friend of Asuna and Setsuna and a powerful healer in her own right, Sakurazaki Setsuna, Shinmei swordswoman and the silent boydguard, Yukihiro Ayaka, the class-rep and mortal enemies with Asuna, Evangline A.K. Mcdowell and Chachamaru, evil vampire and robot turn good, etc. Along with the supporting cast and magical elements, Mahou Sensei Negi is fairly interesting and original. (However, it does not stand up to the manga as you will see later.)

Rating: 7

Art

This is where the anime falls flat on its face. Regrettably, I felt that the producers/directors spent too much of the bugdet on the music and not enough on the art. There was not enough shading on the characters, the lines were blurry, and the characters looked funny and not proportional. Sometimes there was good animation and most of the time none. There was a lot of flat colors with no shades or nuances added to it... crappy. On top of that, if you look closely, all the spells that Negi casts looks all the same with not much variation = laziness. If anyone was to make anime, one cannot be lazy, and I felt that the people behind the anime project were lazy or had budget constraints, I don't know. Whatever the case is, the art had to be improved and it pained me everytime I saw an episode at the bad animation quality that the anime was offering to me compared to the manga.

Rating: 2

Sound

Now here is where the anime shines. As aforementioned, I felt they spent too much of the budget and time into the music/sound and the anime did astound me with its music. The openning song is techno and fast-paced and awesome sounding, "Happy Material Go", and they used various versions throughout the series with different girls singing it. Then episode 24's opening song to commerate Asuna's death was perfect, sad, slow, and melancholic - absolutely great and I even know how to play the tune on flute. The ending songs including "Kagayaku Kimi e", "Oshiete Hoshii zoh Shisho", and "Happy Material Go acoustic version" for eps 23. They were pretty good as well and gave the anime a nice touch. The best part of the music was in between the series, such as in episode 24 where Negi finds Asuna's remains and the piano/techno in the background blows me away. Later on, in episode 26, the entire fight scene with the Demon King had totally crazy music that made it the perfect fighting scene, aside from the animation quality. Other than that, the young seiyuus voicing the 31 girls were excellent and I couldn't ask for any better performance, except that Setsuna's should have been a bit higher and Konoka's a bit lower. Together, all 31 girls have produced the OST and numerous other soundtracks, again proving the awesome music quality and the much spent budget/time.

Rating: 10

Presentation

Here is the other major downfall. The bad things included many and I will elaborate. One major pain was the fact that the anime tried to follow manga but also tried their own twists; it just made the episodes drag out longer and end up as fillers. For the most part, I felt that the series was a major filler up until the Kyoto trip story arc and the Asuna's death story arc... even then they butchered it up. Some examples of filler episodes and killing the manga storyline was the episode where Negi enters some kind of contest and other girls try to get him. That was a waste of an episode and it was told better in the manga with actual kissing and the ogre teacher Nita... quite unfortunate. Another thing the anime butchered was the Kyoto trip arc; what in the world happened? They left so many minor plots out and characters that it left me highly disappointed. What happened to Kotaro, the acting village? To try to cram 3 volumes worth of manga into 3-5 something episodes doesn't cut it. Akamatsu's stuff is better than that. The things that makes up for the series was the brilliant acting and the Asuna's death story arc which is completely original in my eyes. That story arc gives Negima a sadder and more serious aspect to Negima and implements the right music and acting that makes up for the entire series. On top of that, episode 23 was delayed for a long time, and fans eagerly waiting for only found out that it was mostly dialogue and a filler episode to lead to Asuna's death. As a whole, the Negima series disappointed me with some redeeming qualities.

Rating: 4

Final Verdict

5.6667 (average)

Reviewed by g-money, Dec 19, 2005

Comments

  1. littlejonny100 Retired Moderator Dec 19, 2005

    I think there was different opening music for each month that it was aired over, as well as a different voice actor for each of the 31 girls, wasteful? Maybe but I agree with you though that the music was fantastic, especially the fast paced ones.

    I also agree that the animation itself left me very, very disappointed. They make Asunas eyes look really strange in the anime and i also find that there are certain parts where everyones heads and bodies look completly different to other parts, they look almost drafted, or is that just me?

    I haven't reads the fan translated manga so i'm only up to date with the english released ones. I thought a few episodes were really useful such as the ghost girl Sayo. The whole part with Asuna dying kinda surprised me too. Was that or will that be apart of the manga as well. On a side note I found many important things were half left out. Some things they show seem to be directed at people who have read the manga, none come to mind right now but things that seem to point at bits of story from the manga that where ignored in the series.

  2. FFenril Dec 19, 2005

    The anime is worth the mark you gived it...
    Good review, you pointed almost all the bad and good points (awful animation, bad presentation, the Kyoto arc which was spoiled...)
    The 2 episodes for Kyoto were the only ones which were good, I think, but too much things were forgotten... (Negi VS Kotaro T________T)
    And for the last arc, Asuna's death, it *could* have been good but it was... I mean, Asuna dies suddenly, all alone with Negi, and NOBODY thinks there's something wrong? I was really astonished when I saw the 24th episode, where everybody is crying but nobody *thinks*. The end of the arc was good, but well...
    If the anime had been a clean copy of the manga it would've been waaay better...
    I still think a second season of Negima with another company can be good, especially when you see the last mangas : Action, action, and more action! (Wilheim, then Mahora's festival & the tournament...)

  3. wings Dec 20, 2005

    ive never watched the anime of MSN (lol?).
    asuna died in the anime o_O?
    which epi was that?
    i only watched the manga and i thought it was great.

  4. fawna-chan Dec 20, 2005

    Hm...I didn't like the anime's art either...but the manga's okay...And you went over everthing...I never seen the anime though...but I've seen the cover...it's just weird.

  5. AnimeFan159 Dec 22, 2005

    This anime is absolutly terrible, I'd give it lower in art and story line. Why couldnt it be like the manga. At least Love Hina was very very similar to the manga so the story line wasnt all that bad.

  6. xXSpawnOfSinXx Dec 24, 2005

    for any that would like to hear some good news, it has been announced that Negima will be completely remade for the DVD release and finally reach the glory it was supposed to have if it turned out like the manga. The team that worked on Fafner will also be working on some of the episodes. I just pray the episodes will be as great as the manga and for a second season.

  7. g-money Dec 26, 2005

    Let's hope indeed... I'm a pretty fair reviewer (check out my reviews on Futari Ecchi and Erementar Gerad) and Negima seriously went below my standards. As for the second season, I'm just plain not interested anymore.

  8. Kryuzei Dec 31, 2005

    wew...for once, i am shocked that you rated very low for this series..but at least you reviewed the anime not the manga....(maybe -.-)
    anyway, i agree, the art is really bad, and some of them are Manga-Coloured scene and the line,color,proportion,unique part of the manga's art didn't appear at the anime...very dissapointing.
    at least, the Asuna's death part is very amazing..^^

  9. stukovliau Jan 06, 2006

    Well, i am shocked that this anime is so low rating.
    i more like its manga... more dramatic ploted and more funny.
    anime...quite good i think.
    well, i encourage go see its manga than anime...

  10. ultima-weapon Feb 15, 2006

    well.... for me te anime really sux..... although the endin is beyind my expectations..... the overall storyline really get somethnig wrong.....
    look, asuna forgotten everything about magics when she was small...... n how the hell does she knows that she was going to die and have a contract with satan (or demon whatsoever) when she was small? sadly, tis anime series really makes me dissapointed......
    Although i'm crazy about the manga (man! it's just fantastic!).........

  11. blade12 Apr 08, 2006

    yeah. i basically read it for the story line... ^_^;;;; not the sex appeal, mind you. but I still think the anime version looks alot alot watered down

  12. Nemmy Apr 11, 2006

    I, liek many others, hate the anime. The manga however is extremely awesome. I really like how Ken took a different direction with the main male character in the harlem series where Negi isn't a loser! unlike Keitaro.

  13. cassandraronald May 21, 2006

    Quote by wingsive never watched the anime of MSN (lol?).
    asuna died in the anime o_O?
    which epi was that?
    i only watched the manga and i thought it was great.


    the ep in which asuna died was in ep 25 i think and asuna DID not die.

  14. da3mon Jul 08, 2006

    Does anyone know the song from episode 13 when negi leaves schooll...that indian song...if someone has it please could you give ema link or we could figure a way to send it to me please :D

  15. ZonSlashSykato Jan 04, 2007

    the retelling of negima was much better and higher grapics

  16. super-anime-fan Apr 20, 2007

    Quote by g-money
    et's hope indeed... I'm a pretty fair reviewer (check out my reviews on Futari Ecchi and Erementar Gerad) and Negima seriously went below my standards. As for the second season, I'm just plain not interested anymore.


    Well if you compare the anime and the manga the manga IS a lot better. I think they just said, hey lets make an anime, and decided to do everything lazy like because... well it's just strange. The characters look SO weird in the anime. Until you get the "DVD version" supposed to be enhanced and artwork better? I think not, well ok a little better artwork but they basically just added more color.

    Definitely though, if you read the manga it's a lot better, I remember when I first watched the anime. I was like I remember this I saw this at the store. I watched it and it was pretty good. But when I read the manga I was like... wow, unbelievable, this is AWSOME. So you know, it's hard to get me to say something like that. Trust me.

  17. uzumakixhinata Jan 29, 2010

    well, Since I love Negima..I have nothing against the anme..It's pretty bland yes, but I do enjoy watching it..Ahaha..Since I fell in love with the manga before the anime,I looked over the fact that the art is not good..Though sometimes, it's a bit distracting. OVA animations were pretty good..They used gradients..Think so?ahehe..For Sesuna's voice I absolutely adore it.I can ask no more..It's Yuu anyways..XD..For Konoka too..I love listening o her voice..^^

  18. agasca311 Nov 08, 2012

    You can buy this anime for a cheap price at www.arturoga.gps5.com/shop.php

page 1 of 1 18 total items

Only members can post replies, please register.

Warning: Undefined array key "cookienotice" in /var/www/minitokyo/www/html2/footer.html on line 73
This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Read more.