Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_ACCEPT_LANGUAGE" in /var/www/minitokyo/www/includes/common.inc.php on line 360 Wiegraf30's Scrapped Princess Tv Review - Minitokyo
»

Wiegraf30's Scrapped Princess Tv Review

Scrapped Princess

Scrapped Princess tv Review

There is a bad prophecy told to the king that a baby will be born in his kingdom. The baby is said to bring chaos and destruction into the world, and the cursed baby is Pacifica Casull, the newborn princess that will bring the curse at the age of 16.

To escape the prophecy, the baby was buried in the darkness right after birth, and no one is suppose to talk about this omen. However, one assasins after another is coming to kill Pacifica, who is not suppose to exist in the first place, and so the elder brother and sister of Pacifica: Shannon and Raquel, sets on a journey to protect their only sister.
Synopsis by: Niomea

Story & Characters

When the Church (and since it's anime, the church is inherently evil) decides that baby Pacifica is the one who will bring about the apocalypse when she reaches age 16, she is tossed over a cliff by a legion of knights. Those knights should have chosen decapitation instead, because the girl survived the fall, and her two older siblings, Raquel and Shannon, have taken it upon themselves to protect her with their lives.

It's an interesting concept, but the plot goes nowhere fast. On several occasions, characters just don't act the way they ought to. For instance, in the first episode, a soldier named Chris is sent to assassinate Pacifica. Pacifica's siblings get distracted fighting some other foes, and Chris sneaks up right beside his target. Rather than kill her, he instead asks her if all she does is stand behind her protectors, doing nothing at all as they fight for her life. Which brings up another point; realism in conversation is sacrificed for the purpose of cliched, and all too predictable plot development. In a well done story, plot development, and characters' revelations take place inside of realistic conversations and actions. In this regard, Scrapped Princess falls flat on its face.

The characters are uninspired and boring. The soldier Leo aspires to be a champion of justice, but finds that becoming a knight could lead to becoming a leader of injustice. He's like Amelia from Slayers, only his character is bringly predictable. He never does anything significant for the plot, and I often wondered why he was there in the first place. Most of the other character suffer in the same why, especially that Rei (Evangelion) clone, but the biggest problem was Pacifica herself. Almost every episode, she'd pop the question of whether or not it'd be better if she just died. Now, given her position, I understand that it would be an issue, but it's an issue that is at the forefront of the series the whole time, but is never truly addressed. The only whiney main character I've ever enjoyed was Shinji Ikari from Evangelion, and that was because the story revolved around him discovering his problems and him trying to solve them. Pacifica does nothing but complain the entire series, so in that regard, agree with the Peacemakers; the world would be better off with Pacifica dead.

Rating: 3

Art

Though the story is lackluster, the art quality is on par with what we'd expect from an anime these days. The frames don't shake at all, and the coloring scheme is quite vivid and moody. My only complaint is the lack of variety. None of the towns can really be distinguished from each other, and the same goes for fields and forests. The only thing that helps us tell each location apart is what the characters say, who thankfully tells us where they're at or where they're going. The battles are done well; none of that 'single character frame with shooting lines in the background' stuff.

Rating: 7

Sound

No real complaints here. The soundtrack doesn't have any flaws, aside from its lack of memorability. The only song I can remember off the top of my head is the stupid eyecatch with the accordion music that often breaks the mood of the show. The song isn't that big of a deal, but it's so unlike any of the other themes in the show, and it makes you wonder if the producers were high when they made it.

The voice acting, on the other hand, is not a problem. The characters are voiced well, and if the characters had gotten some better dialogue, I would've given Sound a better score than this.

Rating: 4

Presentation

As an RPG veteran, I had a lot of problems watching this show an enjoying myself at the same time. Cliches left and right, with cookie cutter characters (minus Shannon) that are thrown into the mix in an attempt to get something decent in the end. The humor wasn't terrible, but it wasn't great either.

The stereotypical "that incident" in this show was a war from 4000 years ago. There's nothing wrong with referring to a war 4000 years ago, but it you're going to, at least make the war a critical point in the story (Xenogears for the PSX is a prime example of a pertinent conflict 4000 years ago). Honestly, they could've just omitted that whole war and the story would have flowed almost the exact same way. Because few of the events really rely on each other (no cause and effect), I quickly got the feeling that the producers made up the story as they went along.

There are some moments where the show actually becomes original, but it never was a good thing. Take the ending, when the audience discovers the true form of the world. Yes, it was original; no, it wasn't good.

This show presents all the mediocre aspects of anime storytelling. Heed my warning; avoid Scrapped Princess at all costs

Rating: 2

Final Verdict

3.5000 (below average)

Reviewed by Wiegraf30, Oct 16, 2004

Comments

  1. cyberstorm Oct 16, 2004

    It seems to me that you decided to dispice this series before you started watching it since you didn't really understand the series, i'm sorry, your review was good as a review... you didn't reveal much about the show you told your own opinions and such, and well, the review certainly brought diversity to the scale of reviews.

    Well, i can't change your opinion (i wish you could see this series for what it truly is though), but it raises a question, how can an anime that's THAT bad get 5/5 by THEManime and get Best Fantasy Anime 2003 by AnimeReactor.net (to name a few awards it has been given)?

    I like different opinions, it brings diversity... but I'd still like to object since it would be such a waste if this made people think twice before watching it... :\

    I'm not doubting that there is people that share your opinion though, so do not fear... XD

  2. Wiegraf30 Oct 17, 2004

    I didn't despise the series before I started watching it. I went into that anime thinking "Alright, it's about time another good fantasy show came around." It isn't that I didn't understand the story (having played RPGs most my life, the story was actually TOO easy for me to understand. I could predict what was about to happen with striking accuracy), it's that once I understood the story, I didn't care for it.

    I admit, I'm much more critical of shows than most people, but I'm going to call things the way I see them.
    As for the awards it got, the only thing that comes to mind is that there were slim pickings in 2003.

    i know you're not insulting me, cyberstorm; I just feel I should clarfiy my position.

  3. cyberstorm Oct 17, 2004

    Well, i guess that the show was a bit too light then since the things you couldn't perdict was things that annoyed you, like why the "bad" guy didn't kill her in the first episode and such... what the series tries to show is that everyone is human and the bad people aren't neccessarely as bad as the "good" project them to be, it's also about the struggle to gain freedom and a fight against fate...

    I myself can also for the most part forsee storylines and such, i've stopped watching hollywood productions a long time ago since the latest movie that left me asking what'll happen in the end was The Matrix... and it wasn't even produced in Hollywood ^_^'
    But Scrapped Princess was and still is the only anime that left me stunned by how well they fitted all the pieces of the complex puzzle they founded in the beginning while at the same time showing the "bad" guys from a totally different perspective than usual...

    Don't take me as one of them stupid fan boys that's protecting their precious favourite anime, but i seriously think that you've missed the storyline and message in the series a bit, or you simply doesn't like the light and comical tone they gave to a rather dark theme...

    Actually i think that i'm going to write a review on it myself XD

  4. rayearth Nov 04, 2004

    I think it's a quite good anime (even better than kiddy grade or star ocean ex I think), and I like how the characters progress even though it didn't reveal some of the characters past. it deserves 8.5 overall in my opinion.

  5. Miyu-DX Nov 09, 2004

    Edited :well...., can i say my opinion? its interesting to see ur review wiegraff, this gives me a new point of view, but i think ure a bit too harsh..., for me, this series deserves 8 ^^(well for me at least),well...., maybe just as akitsu said, this is one of those love 'em or hate 'em. but, this is an enjoyable anime, at least not for die hard rpg er fans (dont be offended please ^_^' ), its true that the story are kind of slow in the beginning, i even feel asleep XD , but when the puzzles begin to unravel in the middle, this series,well, get interesting (again, at least for me ^_^' ).....,well the plot of course is nothing if u compare it to masterpiece like xenosaga and ff7, im a rpg er, at least i know that what rpg is a crap and what rpg is a good one, and i can definitely say that, if u compare ScrapPri with xenosaga, its like child writing with an adult writing maybe (forgive me if i give a bad comparison, i hv difficulty writing with english :sweat: ), we know of course that the creator of xenosaga spend a helluva lot more research than ScrapPri, a really lot more, they even hv to put all the story in 8 eps of games isnt it rite?
    well....,my point of view is that, this is not a hardweight (again sorry for my bad english) that needs a lot of thinking, i mean, i watch anime to relieve my stress^^ (at least for me), well, maybe this series is for casual anime fans, not for diehard animefans, and dont compare this wtih heavy one like evangelion, (im one of the people that dont watch all the evangelion eps, coz i dont understand too much ^_^' ,forgive me), cuz it would be CrapPrincess not ScrappedPrincess XD ....,
    okay, maybe Pacifica complains too much..., afterall, shes is just a under teen, well? and maybe shes design to be the kind of spoiled kid, (maybe some people find that is annoying,at least for me its not ^^) imagine that if theres female version of Shinji in this series as the main char, or stereotype chara in every anime, awwwww....,give me the creeps XD ,well, every anime has its own unique char maybe, we cant expect most anime will have a similar goody char that populer anime has, thats just too boring maybe.....
    for Shanon, i think hes a well planned char also...., i like his character, i have brother too, i kinda understand, it would be nice to hv a brother like him, too bad Raquelle is not developed well enough, as for Leo, hes just alrite, u can see that he developed a bit throughout the story(only a bit tho^^),theres still chars that is worse, but, its alrite overall for me^^.....
    the only complain i have is, the music..... :sweat: the music (esp the ed theme) is very horrible to me......,okay..., now about the ending, i kinda love the ending, a happy ending is always my fav, dont really like dark gloomy ending although i dont hate that
    okay, phew...., wrote too much..., that should be enough...
    well, please...,please dont feel offended wiegraff^^, i really think u hv an interesting point of view, its just that im one of the ScrapPri fans, i just feel want to xpress my opinion...^^, okay, hv a good day

  6. Wiegraf30 Nov 09, 2004

    No worries, Miyu-DX, I'm not offended in the least; I'm just glad you know where I'm coming from on some of these issues.

    Just so people know, yes, I realize that I graded this series very toughly. I didn't grade the series badly because I don't like a happy series or a series with various moods. I graded it badly because I thought the series had no definite atmosphere, or 'feel' to it; without that, you can't get involved in a series.

    I don't always (or usually for that matter) look for a Xenogears or Evangelion-esque plot; I absolutely loved Azumanga Daioh, and that series had absolutely no plot to speak of. My problem with the series was that the atmosphere was boring, the funny parts weren't funny, the dramatic parts felt contrived, and most of the characters were people we've already seen in other series. If you want a GOOD series with a mix of happiness and moodiness, watch Trigun.

    The idea of portraying the 'bad guys' as just other people with a difference in opinion is nothing new (not that I dislike the idea, it's just that the series doesn't break any new ground in this regard), but when you try to get that message across to your audience by having the assassin carry on a casual conversation with his target when he's got a damn good opportunity to kill her, then you've got a contingency problem. When characters open up, especially to their enemies, the situation has to be right; if you can't do that, the relationships lose their realism.

    Maybe it's because I'm no longer an adolescent, but I can't stand the whiny main characters (expect Shinji, since the theme of Evangelion deals heavily with that issue). Every episode, Pacifica would bitch about how she was causing everyone to die, and every episode, everyone around her had to cheer her up. And it wasn't like she learned something new about herself every time she asked the question; she just got told the same crap over and over again. It got annoyingly repetitve.

    I guess, as Akitsu said, that this is a love or hate series; you all know my stance.

  7. Miyu-DX Nov 09, 2004

    lol, after all u said about pacifica, i begin to wonder why i like her in the first place, maybe i should hv hate her^^...., well, doesnt matter anymore....
    thx for giving us a nice point of view^^
    hv a nice day then^^

  8. Lylani Jul 07, 2005

    I have to say that Scrapped Princess to me was very interesting anime. I like it so far, my only problem is that there not that much background but I guess when your making a series everything at some point gets revield. Right now I've only seen vol's 1-2 and I was told that the series get good after that...

    I have to say though if your not one of those Scify-Fanticy people then that might be why all you disapointed fanticy lovers didn't find the seiries all too amuzing.

  9. FrostBlade13 May 01, 2006

    Well, I can see why would might dislike it, to a point. I really enjoyed Scrapped Princess and Trigun, but to each his own, it truely is a love or hate anime.

  10. nainoi Sep 27, 2009

    what happen with score?

  11. rukasu44 Dec 25, 2010

    so low, is that so bad?

  12. back07 Sep 24, 2012

    thanks for the nice review
    :)

page 1 of 1 13 total items

Only members can post replies, please register.

Warning: Undefined array key "cookienotice" in /var/www/minitokyo/www/html2/footer.html on line 73
This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Read more.