Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_ACCEPT_LANGUAGE" in /var/www/minitokyo/www/includes/common.inc.php on line 360 Drakonshie's Hikaru no Go Tv Review - Minitokyo
»

Drakonshie's Hikaru no Go Tv Review

Hikaru no Go

Hikaru no Go tv Review

Hikaru Shindo is a lazy, under-achieving 6th grader until the day he finds an old goban in his grandfather's storage shed. The goban is haunted by the ghost of the greatest Go player of the Heian era, Fujiwara no Sai, who has spent a thousand years seeking the Hand of God; the Divine Move. Sai's soul attaches to Shindou's, so only Shindou can see or hear him, and Sai wants only one thing: to play Go.
Shindou has no interest in Go, but he takes Sai to a go salon to allow him to play. There Shindou and Sai meet Akira Touya, the same age as Shindou and a gifted Go player. Shindou is fascinated by both Touya's intensity and Sai's love of the game. Soon he develops his own desire to walk the path of Go and become a great player... and Touya's rival.

Description: thefourthvine.

Story & Characters

An ancient spirit inhabits a boy with multicolored hair. Joined in mind and body, the two set off on a quest to climb to the top of their game. Sound familiar? No, it's not "Yu-Gi-Oh;" it's "Hikaru no Go" (hereafter referred to as 'HNG') Based off of the manga by Yumi Hotta and Takeshi Obata, the anime follows the adventures of Shindou Hikaru and his ghost, Fujiwara no Sai, in the world of Go (a Japanese board game), with the goal to reach 'kami no itte' (translated as 'the hand of God' or 'the divine move').

Set in modern Tokyo, the story begins with Hikaru, a 6th grader, finding an old Go board in his grandfather's attic. Between his friend and him, Hikaru was the only one who spots the blood on the board. With this, Sai "awakens" and takes over Hikaru. Sai's love for Go remains strong, even after his suicide in the Heian period. His ultimate goal of reaching 'kami no itte' looks good, now that he has found a new vessel. Unfortunately for him, Hikaru has no interest in Go. But with Sai's help and guidance, Hikaru begins to develop a love for Go. Through trials and tribulations, the pair's relationship grows beyond ordinary symbiosis.

Rating: 8

Art

Unlike "Naruto," the art and animation in HNG seem to be fairly consistent. There is much detail in this anime (ex. flickering lights in rooms and shadows and lights made by passing cars at night).

HNG takes place over a couple of years and the characters develop physically and mentally during this time. It is nice to see a depiction of physical maturation in the animation. [Sorry, guys, there's not much of the girls' physical development for you to see] The aging process is subtle, but made obvious during flashbacks in later episodes.

The animation also effectively portrays comical situations. For example, remember how humorous it was in "Full Metal Alchemist" to see Al's various facial expressions on his armor? It is similar in HNG when Sai's face goes chibi as he deviates from his usual seriousness.

To spare viewers from watching an ordinary Go board being randomly decorated with black and white stones during games, the anime offers a few alternatives/additions:
- the presence of action lines
- the use of faded moving pictures across the Go board
- the presentation of the game in an abstract, isolated setting

The animation sequence for the openings and endings are mediocre and mostly feature headshots of various characters, but it's understandable since it's about a board game and, therefore, wouldn't have the fast-paced action animated openings you would expect from action animes.

Though solid and consistent, the art and animation makes little attempt to go beyond large eyes and unnaturally-colored hair.

Rating: 7

Sound

THEME SONGS: I personally like all of the openings and endings of HNG. For J-pop fans, it has a nice mix of different styles, ranging from dance to rock. The signature theme of HNG is its first opening, "Get Over" by dream. It's a catchy pop tune that sets the stage of the anime. I really like the pop/rock flavor of the first ending theme, "Bokura no Bouken" by Kids Alive. Though better suited for an intro, it's fine as an ending and nicely conveys the storyline. Another one of my favorites is "Sincerely" by dream (3rd ending). This alluring piece is supported by beautiful piano melodies and is also worthy of the repeat button. Most of the songs pertain to the story of HNG, but there were a couple that I felt were out of place. Also, the overuse of songs by the pop band dream in the anime (they have 4) limits the diversity of songs.

BACKGROUND MUSIC: Most of the background music is nicely weaved into the story, but it's nothing outstanding. The song "Kami no Itte" may get bothersome due to overplay. Few songs, however, don't seem to fit certain situations. For example, there are times when a majestic, epic-sounding piece is played during trivial matches. I really enjoy the orchestral arrangements of the theme songs. Sometimes, I replay episodes just to hear them.

VOICE ACTING: My heart flutters when I find familiar seiyuus in an anime. Several seiyuus from "Naruto" and "Full Metal Alchemist" are also in HNG. I like how the characters sound age-appropriate for 6th graders. As the anime progresses, Hikaru and his peers age a couple of years, and I was disappointed that the voices did not reflect that. Nevertheless, the voice acting was good, but nothing exceptional.

Rating: 7

Presentation

At 75 episodes, HNG starts out at a steady pace, accelerates in some areas, but drags towards the end. An additional 3 'special' episodes are also part of the anime. Of the three:
- one was a condensed version of the first dozen episodes
- one was a different version of episode 64
- one takes place after the 75th episode and continues the story
In short, the first two weren't really worth watching. The third did not advance the plot as far as I had hoped. I felt the 75th episode provided a better, more reasonable ending than that of the third special.

What HNG does well is developing side characters. For certain minor characters, we are able to understand their motivations and ambitions of playing Go. Unfortunately, some of the more interesting characters that appeared early in the story get reduced down to cameo appearances at the end.

HNG occasionally knocks out several games in one episode to keep the plot moving. What is brilliant about HNG is the presentation of some of the important games. It is quite easy to focus directly on an entire game during these key match-ups. But instead of watching a Go board and immediately following the action, we can see the game through a non-playing character's eyes. This tactic allows us to observe his actions and emotions during the game and to see how Go matches affect other players, also serving to enhance character development.

With an anime about Go, we can obviously expect many intense Go matches. One need not be knowledgeable about Go before watching HNG. The fansubs provide descriptions of moves at the top of the screen and there is also a tutorial with a professional Go player at the end of each episode. There is also enough information through dialogue and thoughts to at least understand who has the advantage in the game.

Despite its flaws, HNG has a high entertainment and addiction value. It is highly recommended for serious viewing, as well as for self-interpretation of unofficial shounen-ai situations [Trust me, there are a lot of them]. HNG has spawned a great interest in Go among its Japanese viewers. By the time you finish this anime, you, too, will be affected by Go, whether it be actively pursuing it as a hobby or researching more about it. Or you could find yourself in my position--subconsciously holding potato chips like Go stones during school lunch.

Rating: 8

Final Verdict

7.6667 (good)

Reviewed by Drakonshie, Oct 24, 2008

Comments

  1. MapleRose Retired Moderator Oct 25, 2008

    Nice review, I especially like the presentation analysis (and watching HNG made me want to learn Go XD) ^__^

    The art section is well-written as well, I like how you analyzed the maturation of the characters in the art, because that's one of the strengths of the series imo. Just one thing though, why comparing the art of HNG to Naruto and FMA? True, those are popular series, but they're not made by the same people as HNG, and not necessarily everyone has seen them.

    Also, I kind of wished you'd reviewed more on the story section instead of just giving an overview of the plot (plot synopsis). What were your thoughts on the story and plot? what about the characters, what are they like? Are they likeable? Did they develop?

    But other than that, nicely written ^^

  2. Melchari Oct 25, 2008

    Your review is concise useful and thorough. I believe I would have netted the story a higher rating myself because writing an action anime about a board game and keeping the audiences attention is amazing at least. However, one's opinion is always subjected to criticism, good job.

  3. Aldarionar Oct 27, 2008

    Yeah very nice work.. i think that the story deserves a better rating too..

  4. Soel-Larg Nov 02, 2008

    This is a nice Revew, than you!
    I'd like to watch this anime

  5. BakagetaKoto Nov 03, 2008

    Thank you for the review, Vine-san. I feel that you represented Hikaru no Go very accurately, and that you put quite a bit of thought into your review.

    (I did enjoy Hikaru no Go, and it's the reason I decided to learn how to play Go. ^^)

  6. Hiime-chan Nov 04, 2008

    wow,nice review *_*, lovely,when i have time i will watch o/

  7. tsuyoshi7171 Feb 21, 2009

    sugoiiiii

  8. narunarunarunaru Feb 28, 2009

    yeyy!

  9. DOUBLESKIPHEART Mar 10, 2009

    It doesn't seem like my type of anime. But nice review none the less. c:

  10. beryl0402 Mar 15, 2009

    cool

  11. chumbariwap123 Apr 21, 2009

    i like the game they are playing but.. i dont know how to play

  12. pigmypuff Jun 03, 2009

    yup..i dunno how to play to.But it like chess maybe

  13. yuyuppi Jun 12, 2009

    i like sai so much ^__^

  14. pmgbapm Jun 23, 2009

    I always watch it!~~

  15. lordryo Jul 21, 2009

    Loved Hikaru no GO, the manga is good too!

  16. ResonantSoul Jul 23, 2009

    ohh Hikaru no Go. xD

  17. Ilona Aug 04, 2009

    Nice review, it reminded me a lot the anime. I especially like the part where you explain how the action is shown.

    I am a big fan of the manga so I watched too the manga even if I knew every line they would say... and also could spot the differences : by example in the manga, it is never said directly that people understood the first game of Hikaru as a new pro was a handicap one. But if some funny, cute scenes were removed, the games are more developped.

    Well I know more about Go now than Chess but even if I know the rules, my attention span is too short for go. I am just good enough to play the first Hikago GBA game, nothing more.

  18. SchRita Aug 23, 2009

    Thanks for the review!

  19. Rodrigo0010 Sep 03, 2009

    good job! nice review

  20. nainoi Sep 11, 2009

    it's so fun anime.
    you will like it.

  21. SchRita Oct 31, 2009

    Thanks for the review!

page 1 of 1 21 total items

Only members can post replies, please register.

Warning: Undefined array key "cookienotice" in /var/www/minitokyo/www/html2/footer.html on line 73
This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Read more.