Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_ACCEPT_LANGUAGE" in /var/www/minitokyo/www/includes/common.inc.php on line 360 yuizaki's Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind Tv Review - Minitokyo
»

yuizaki's Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind Tv Review

Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind

Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind tv Review

In the post-apocalyptic future, large parts of the world have been swallowed up by forests of poisonous fungi. The remaining humans live near the fungus and its monstrous insectoid inhabitants trying to prevent its spread. One of the human kingdoms, the peaceful Valley of Wind, is swallowed up in the machinations of its larger warmongering neighbors. The princess of the Valley of the Wind, Nausicaa, has hidden potential and may yet change the fate of the world.

Written by edelriclvr

Story & Characters

**Please note, the review score in my review is somewhat normally distributed, meaning an anime with score of 5 is average (NOT 6 as it is scaled on final verdict!), 7 is VERY good, and 10 means "cannot be improved any further". I'm doing this to accurately reflect truly great works (and crap*y work too ^^;). Please add around 2 points to the overall rating to convert it to the scale most of other people use. Also, anime are reviewed within the scope of anime, anime-movie are viewed within the scope of anime-movie... and so on. Please remember that anime is often given 10 times more time to present story compared to anime-movie!**

*Informal Commentary*
I am surprised to see that there is only one review written (but it's really nice one) on Nausicaa of the Valley of Wind (Kaze no Tani no Nausicaa.) This is Hayao Miyazaki's first anime-movie work made in 1984. The world of Nausicaa is, in many respects, illustrates his anime-making style.

The world is set in far distant future; the time after people acquired technology of inter-stellar travel but has destroyed themselves in a mysterious war known as "Seven Days of Fire." The war is suspected to be the primary cause of the appearance of "Fukai", or the "Sea of Corruption," a toxic jungle inhabited by huge insects, trees, and fungi that creates toxic air. Humans can only go there with special gas mask on. Habitable land where humans and the creatures that exist today live is slowly encroached by ever-growing Fukai. The main character of the movie is Nausicaa, a 16 year-old girl and the only child among 11 children the Chieftain of a small city-state village Kaze no Tani, or the Valley of the Wind, made. Although the village is safeguarded from Fukai by the air that blows from the "Sea of Acid," the village is still being affected by the toxins of Fukai, such as fall in fertility rate (10 children born before Nausicaa died for mysterious reason.)

Nausicaa is a "Wind Rider" (Wind user in Japanese), who can use a powered "Kite" known as Moewe (please pronounce in German, which sounds like Mehve) and a pilot of Gunship that has been serving as the primary defensive force of the village. While she enjoys nature, which unfortunately means toxic Fukai in her world, finds herself having have to assume the role of the next chieftain and a protector of the village.

One day, a huge Cargo Aircraft crashes near the Village. As a wind rider, she goes to find the incident and to save lives. However, she couldn't save anyone, but she was able to hear the last words by the princess of Pejite, which was to burn away the cargo. The day after the crash, militant state Tolmekia invades the valley, reveals the fact that it has invaded Pejite to capture the "God Warrior" which could be used as a mighty weapon. Nausicaa is then forced to participate in Tolmekia's military campaign with her Village's Gunship. On the way, she finds herself having to guide Tolmekian authority to not to violate the taboo of Fukai, and to protect her village from enraged Ohm, a mighty insect that acts as the defender of Fukai.

Rating: 8

Art

I must say that the artwork of Nausicaa is one of the worst in Miyazaki's series (but still one of the best in anime industry!!) even taking into account that the anime was made in 80's. Because he was not very famous at the time, there was a serious budget problem; in fact, the production of the movie was once halted. Nevertheless, his artwork is certainly of the top quality. As usual with his anime, he puts a large effort into gadgets and backgrounds because, given the extremely limited time of a movie, pictures inform viewers of his imagined world.

To my regret, in some places his use of mechanics design looks out of place. For example, Tolmekia uses tank that looks like Panzerkampfwagen III, Germany's tank used in WWII, when the princess of Tolmekia claims that they have re-discovered the technology existed before the Seven Days of Fire. I suspect that this is because Miyazaki wanted to materialize his personal interest and hobby through this movie. In his other movies, you do still see some of his hobby, like the fortress in Laputa, but it is a really good thing that he stopped throwing in such things out of place later on. Nevertheless, I must say that his artwork is of top quality and the design of certain mechanics, such as Moewe is very nice and scientifically correct that proto-type of Moewe is ACTUALLY BEING RESEARCHED in Japan. If anyone has been to the international exhibition in Japan in 2005, you might have been very lucky to see the model of Moewe known as "Personal Jet Glider."

Rating: 7

Sound

Not only the technology of computer-assisted designing has improved since the 80's, but so did the sound. Joe Hisashi, a well-known anime-soundtrack artist, made Nausicaa soundtrack but you probably will feel that the music is somewhat lackluster. Some music is really of top quality while for others some people might dislike. However, the bottom line is that they all match the scenes/movie.

The obvious flaw in the sound is the use of stereotypical peripheral sound, such as gunfire or wind. They sound as if they came out of an archive. I suspect that Joe Hisashi at the time was not very used to creating music, as it was one of his earliest work. Later on, the quality of his music improves dramatically. In this movie, you do hear some music of talent of Joe Hisashi, but not very often.

Rating: 5

Presentation

This movie is one of the first works of Miyazaki and apparently, he had no idea how to create a good movie. His ideas a superb but he couldn't put them into one single material. If he re-makes Nausicaa now he would certainly create much better one, but he was not used to film production at the time. However, while being an entertainment film, this movie was able to deliver its underlying concept. Movies often have a concept to deliver besides entertainment value, and in this case, it is about the protection of nature and animals. In fact, the movie won a recommendation by the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF, or the World Wildlife Fund, the most respected NGO for the protection of the environment). I judge the presentation rating of the movie to be above average, not because of the way it is presented for entertainment purpose (below average in that respect), but for delivering serious underlying concept to viewers.

The overall rating comes out to be quite low; however, this anime is strongly recommended as an early work of Miyazaki. It has many flaws, but everywhere you see the great talents of Ghibli anime production team.

Rating: 6

Final Verdict

6.6667 (above average)

Reviewed by yuizaki, Apr 24, 2006

Comments

  1. Kidder Apr 24, 2006

    hmmmm, I've always been a huge fan of Miyazaki's films, so I don't totally agree with your review. The anime was based on a 5 volume (I think?) manga series created by Miyazaki as well. Although the film plot has obviously been edited from the original manga plot, it still retains the underlying moral of the story. BTW I highly recommend all fans of Nausicaa to buy the manga. There's amount of info that had to be omitted from the film.

    In terms of art, most (if not all) character, vehicle and background designs have remained the same as in the manga. To me his usage of German WWII Panzer tank designs was a symbolic representation of the tyranny of the Nazis. The presence of a corrupt military regime is one he uses again in his later films such as Laputa and Princess Mononoke.

    I agree with your opinion on the music. Hisashi's later compositions for Laputa were far better and memorable. Nausicaa did not quite have the symphonic beauty that Laputa achieved.

    Anyways I've gushed enough ^^. Although I don't completely agree with you, I still think it's a well thought out review. Thanks for sharing

  2. yuizaki Apr 24, 2006

    Hi, thanks for your reply which is long enough to make me have a small talk with you.

    I am planning to write a review of the manga as well. The volume depends on the publisher (^^; I think the one I have is the most common one in Japan. I don't know about other countries.

    Anyway, speaking of the mechanics, I believe what I wrote is more likely to be the truth than interpretations such as "symbolic representation." (but of course interpretations of a work is free there is no right/wrong so I won't deny your comment!) But to support my idea, check one of the first mecha designes (mecha sketchbook.) The mecha in his note is not only of tyrant regimes' but there are many others too. However, they are limited to WWII or before, because that's his preference (^^; maybe I should elaborate my language by saying it's his "style." But as the one who actually have seen the rough designs, I must say that he made a right choice in choosing Panzer tank among others because do you know how tanks shaped at the time? Many of them were like a gigantic rock or somehting. German tanks had nice slim design. If I were him, I would choose to use Panzer tank too! or else the scene would look really silly with other tanks.

    btw, just to check if there is any information about the tank and tyranny, but I couldn't get any relevant hits. Interesting hit is that the village economy works like communism lol. Yep, Miyazaki is a pro-commu guy so no wonder he put that into the movie as well. In many aspects the movie is a melting pot of what he has in his mind.

    Speaking of Music, I value the OP and the Battle with Corvette, but that's about it.

    I'm not sure if the regime in Princess Mononoke is corrupt. At the time regime were unable to control many aspects of politics because of the lack of communication. In Laputa, I cannot agree with you that the militaristic regime is corrupt, though I might be saying this in a wrong site ^^;; May be when you or I write Laputa review we can have a small talk... To me I don't think there is any ground such as world setting to base whether the regime in Laputa is corrupt.

    I'm writing really posititve review on Manga so if you are a fan of Nausicaa and didn't like my score on film, don't worry next time! ^^

  3. Kidder Apr 24, 2006

    On reflection, my use of the term "corrupt military regime" was wrong. I never actually noticed Miyazaki's pro-communism attitude. As for the "Panzer" tanks, that's probably just a matter of each person's interpertation. Maybe the Panzer tank design is more significant to the Japanese... or maybe we're just looking to deep into it ^^

    I look foward to reading any other Miyazaki reviews you come up with. Miyazaki's films are a big passion of mine.

  4. Northy Apr 24, 2006

    Actually, I've seen the Nausicaa manga in two "versions". One of them, which is the version I bought, is a four volume manga -- thick books. However, there is also apparently a seven (I think) volume version available, telling the same story (obviously) but with thinner books.

    I agree that the anime could have been better transcribed from the manga, though it would have been nearly impossible to get all four (or seven) volumes into a two hour movie without major cuts. Ideally, for fans of the manga, maybe a movie series would have been better.

    I also agree that people get too caught up on their fave shows not getting eight or more, completely forgetting that, in this case, five points is a decent score. One that, technically, marks an anime worth watching if you're into the kind of show reviewed. Most reviews here is at seven to ten, and a few at below three. The four to six range probably isn't used that often. (Though I get the feeling that people tend to review mostly their favorite shows or their least favorite. No time for the inbetweeners.

  5. yuizaki Apr 24, 2006

    Thanks for your comment Northy.

    I thought of exactly the same thing as you said in the last paragraph. There aren't that many averages, and that's one of the reason that I am being very harsh on my review scores.

    The trick about the movie is that, there was a movie plot, but the director whom Miyazaki needed to ask for approval to make a movie, denied his idea on ground that there is no original story that proves that the movie will be a hit. So we shouldn't say that the movie could've been transcribed from manga in a better way, but rather we should praise that manga was transcribed very well from the movie, although the movie came later ^^;

  6. cheza2283 May 09, 2006

    I think that your review was very thought out, researched and well written! I even learned a thing or two about the movie that I had not picked up while watching it. So thank you! But I am not sure that I agree with your score. I know that you warned that you were going to score more harshly, so I was prepared. But I still believe that this film deserved a better score. Even if it was Miyazaki's first films and it wasn't one of his better ones it was still an awesome film! The plot and story alone were fantastic and I thought that the animation was wonderful. But I will admit that I am probably not as good of a judge as you are at that. I just thought that each character had such animated detail to it that you had not mentioned. That is one thing about Miyazaki's films that amazes me is the magnitude of characters that he comes up with for each film.
    Anyways, you did an excellent review even if I don't agree with your score! Good job!

  7. yuizaki May 10, 2006

    Hi Cheza2283,

    Maybe I am too harsh on Nausicaa the Movie, because the original manga was so good that the goodness of the movie is diminished for me... ^^;;;

    Anyways, thanks for your comment and visiting my review page!

  8. strawberryghost Jun 13, 2006

    Hey, just wanted to stop by here and add my two cents in as well. Although i havent read or even seen any of the Nausicaa manga, i have watched the movie. Several times. ^^ its absolutely gorgeous - the animation adn character developement. There were a lot of paralells that could be drawn between Nausicaa and Princess Mononoke, but just taking the film as it is... it was wonderful. Early on, it did irratate me that she kept randomly talking to herself but furter into the whole plot line it was fine because she pretty much explained what was going on and what not.
    So pretty much - its an awesome movie, but i do not think that it's my absolute favourite out of all the Miyazaki/Studio Ghibli films out there.

  9. Leosam096 Jul 09, 2006

    i love his films and i truly loved this one too, maybe because this movie supports WorlWildlifeFoundation(WWF). :)
    Not only that because of his ideas to tell good stories. Kaze no Tani no Nausicaa is still standing, even though its pretty "old" now.

  10. angelxxuan Banned Member May 20, 2012

    I like how you bothered to place the disclaimer at the first of the review, made it that much nicer to read. this is one of Studio Ghibli's was the start of many I would enjoy, and it haven't let up. I really like this review, how you bothered to put so much effort into it. well done.

page 1 of 1 10 total items

Only members can post replies, please register.

Warning: Undefined array key "cookienotice" in /var/www/minitokyo/www/html2/footer.html on line 73
This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Read more.