Warning: Undefined array key "HTTP_ACCEPT_LANGUAGE" in /var/www/minitokyo/www/includes/common.inc.php on line 360 pariahed's Air Tv Review - Minitokyo
»

pariahed's Air Tv Review

Air

Air tv Review

When he was young, Yukito Kunisaki's mother told him of a winged girl in the sky. Yukito's family has been searching for this girl for generations. Finally, Yukito's journey takes him to a small seaside town where he meets Misuzu Kamio, a girl who is eager to make friends with Yukito. Yukito ends up staying with Misuzu and her mother, Haruka, while he searches for the girl in the sky. In the town, however, there are strange occurences, and as the days pass by, Misuzu starts to have strange dreams.
What is the truth behind Misuzu's dreams and her failing health? And how is everything connected to Yukito and his journey?

The manga adapted from the game is illustrated by Yukimaru Katsura.

Story & Characters

When someone asks me what your favourite anime is, I always reply Kimi Ga Nozomu Eien... then AIR. Why? It's only because of one factor: the characterisation in both series. I'll get to characters later.

The story is simply superb. It's a little confusing at first, especially with the jumps around characters, times and location, but in the end, it's very touching. The originality of the concept deserves a lot of praise. I simply can't stress enough how great the complexity of this storyline is without spoiling it. Take my word for it, it's excellent. Some people think that the complexity of the story is what makes it messy and complex. In some ways, I quite agree; it can be strange, but that does not change the fact that the ending is incredibly touching. It can be seen that most people find the lead up to the climax to be quite boring and pointess, but that just leads up to the development of....

Characters:

The developments of the characters, shall I say, vary. While the side characters don't recieve that much attention, the three main characters Misuzu, Haruka and Yukito, especially the former two, are greatly developed. It's good to see the absence of the annoying young lead male character; Yukito steps into those shoes nicely. The support characters are good at their job: supporting the main female, Misuzu and making the story move along progressively. I have nothing much to say except the fact that story and characters are the facets of this anime that make it so successful.

A/N: I would have given it 9.5/10, but there's no .5 :P

Rating: 9

Art

The art was really well done. However, while I'm not a real big fan of the way the eyes are drawn, this style of art makes it more memorable to me. The appearances of the female characters are, surprisingly, unique, all of them having different hairstyles and clothes (except the school uniform). The backgrounds aren't splendid, but not really average either. It more than serves the purpose of conveying the story.

The most striking aspects of the art in this series would be the ways the sky and water are protrayed. Apart from being used in most if not all of the outdoor scenes, these two are also potent symbols in the story.

Overall, the art of this anime is deceptively cute. It didn't really strike me as a drama/tragedy type of title when I watched the first episode, but overall, it only serves to further heighten the sense of tragedy that befalls the characters. This anime does not disappoint when it comes to art. To the animation artists' credits, the art remains consistent throughout the entire series, which is good to see.

Rating: 10

Sound

The OSTs aren't bad. They are, at the very least, suited to the anime. I, personally however, don't really like them that much, despite their suitability to the genre. However, I really like the background music, performed by, if I'm not mistaken, "I've" (never heard of them though). The two pieces, which have become synonymous with the title are Hane and Summer Lights. Although they are just piano with acoustic accompaniment, they are both very powerful musical pieces. I get a really warm and fuzzy feeling (WAFF), when I listen to the latter piece. However, during the climax of the anime, episode 12, if I remember correctly, the song Aozora sung by Lia really touched me. It was so... fitting for the moment. One of the factors contributing to a great anime is the music and how it fits with the title; as one of the greatest series ever produced, AIR also has music befitting of the series.

Rating: 8

Presentation

As I said previously, this series ranks number 2 on my personal list of animes (out of around 40 odd titles). Number 2 by a long mile, if I may add. In my opinion, and as objectively as I can possibly put it, the storyline, characterisation, art and music all play an integral part in making the series as successful as it has become. The originality and complexity of the storyline are the staples of the anime. Without it, AIR would have just been another shunned and rejected wanna-be drama series. The build up was not only good, but appropriate, and the climax of the story just really touches one's heart.

Overall, excellent series, and as an acquaintance of mine once put it: "pure genius"!

Rating: 10

Final Verdict

9.3333 (very good)

Reviewed by pariahed, Apr 17, 2006

Comments

  1. shoujoboy Apr 18, 2006

    I will first applaud you for saying that KGNE is your favorite, I concur (although watch out, there is an extreme hater of that show out there, and he could make an appearance). But besides that, your review kinda baffles me at times. You do a review based on your own personal enjoyment of the show and how you view the merits overall. To see "I'm not a big fan", "don't really like them that much" and "aren't splendid" in categories you gave a perfect 10 is rather perplexing. It almost seems as if you gave higher scores to categories not deserving of them so as to inflate the overall score. Just my thought.

    It's clear by your verbage that you really enjoyed this show, but it seems that it could be rather misleading to others that may read this review. But that's just my two cents, do with them what you want.

  2. pariahed Apr 19, 2006

    Quote by shoujoboyI will first applaud you for saying that KGNE is your favorite, I concur (although watch out, there is an extreme hater of that show out there, and he could make an appearance). But besides that, your review kinda baffles me at times. You do a review based on your own personal enjoyment of the show and how you view the merits overall. To see "I'm not a big fan", "don't really like them that much" and "aren't splendid" in categories you gave a perfect 10 is rather perplexing.

    yeah, i know about that kgne hater...

    i guess i shouldn't have used the word "splendid" or any other positive term like that in conjuction with a "not"... however, i gave the categories a perfect 10 because, although i would have done otherwise, whatever the director did (forgot his name) was suited to the anime, and in that way achieved the best possible result.

    thanks for your input though, i'll keep that in mind when i write my next review.

  3. Northy Apr 19, 2006

    An extreme hater? What does that person do?

    I mean, there are shows being talked about on this site that I hate with all my heart, but others have given positive reviews. That doesn't mean that I will give them a hard time about it, though. So.... I guess I'm not an extreme hater or something. ^^;;

    You've gotten me curious now. :P

  4. SebastianvonKane Apr 23, 2006

    I don't agree with you. In fact, I found it to be really annoying. The history in the very end turns to be pointless.
    A history begins from a summer carnival and ends in zero.
    NAH! Useless.
    If I knew it was going to be like this, I would just watched the movie, which has a better ending (not so zero).

  5. yuizaki Apr 26, 2006

    I must say that the story of AIR doesn't worth 9. It is below average, around 4 or 3.

    I'm saying this because I know exactly what happened in the productoin process. As you might know, the anime is based on a famous H-game. The H-game is a really great one, in fact, if you rank all the H-games released in Japan AIR will definitely be in the top 3. However, because of the complex grand story and multiple heroines, when making OVA producers had to resolve the problem of time issue. OVA is only 13 episodes, but to put the grand storyline of the H-game was just impossible. However, the production team did it anyway (mistake 1) which turned out to be a miserable failure. Furthermore, to serve all fans, the productoin team decided to make a story for every heroine (mistake 2). Have you noticed that the episodes in the first couple of episodes have absolutely nothing to do with the main story of Misuzu? AIR TV has reasons to be derogated by the people who know the original story, like me.

    However, I agree with you that the presentation is 10/10. I cannot believe that I was so touched to such an anime with messed up storyline. Really, it's extremely rare for me to get touched by an anime. I still think the whole anime is really bad, but I would be lying to myself if I say the presentation was bad too.

    ... or perhaps I am setting standard too high because I know the original?

  6. steffic Jun 03, 2006

    the review is great! but i'll give the rating 10 instead ^-^

    but also i personally take it that the op is soo nice.. n fit in the story too^-^

    AIR is just great! the depth of the storyline is very nice.. i think the first couple of eps supports the whole story of the girl in the sky.. mebbe if u dun agree, u should try to understand more before jumping into conclusions.. i think the reason why many opposed to this anime is that the heavy storyline may burden those who dislike too many thinking in watching anime.. most even luv the AIR movie, which i think is not as deep and so plainly made.. the graphic loses it's cuteness^^.. although the story is indeed not as heavy, the kind of story that even haywire *from prison break* would have understand.. no offense at all, but saying that this anime is based on H game n so it's bad and stuff.. isn't it a weak stand? i also know the original story, but... for a producer who can turn out a H story into a very cute, touching anime, i think he has done just the perfect job..

    this anime is really good.. esp for those who are witty enough to understand what was actually happening in the series ^^

    GAO
    =steff=

  7. eonir Jan 19, 2007

    The higher the verdict is, the better is the review :D

    You should have given a "9" in the sound. Why? Each time I hear the first second of the opening - I'm unable to stop listening. It's stunning :D
    When you hear the sound wind, you know that "Air" is the name of the series :D

page 1 of 1 7 total items

Only members can post replies, please register.

Warning: Undefined array key "cookienotice" in /var/www/minitokyo/www/html2/footer.html on line 73
This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Read more.